In Guilty 2, it is now one year later. Barker had been injured making his escape, and now sports an eye patch, a hook for a left hand, a rubber prosthetic penis (they shot it right off!), and can only talk with the aid of an electronic voice box. Somewhat hard to believe, but Gayle has come back to finish her interview with Barker, despite everything that happened to her. In the one-on-one interview, Gayle admits that while she was sickened by what happened to her, she had also never come so many times! So while Barker continues telling her about his last victim, she openly and unabashedly proceeds to masturbate in front of him!

Most of the story is told in flashback, as Barker recounts all the tortures he did to his final victim, Penelope Pace. As in the first tape, the abuse continues, as first Barker has Penelope hanging by her wrists while tied to a pole, rope encircling her head, and gagged with a large blue ball gag, as drool oozes out from it. Very nice bondage, and although nothing much really happens in this scene, Barker tells Gayle that he left her like that for two days.

Next, Barker ties Penelope up in a unique position, twisted up like a prezel, with her hands behind her and her legs tied up together over the top of her head. She is ballgagged and forceably raped up the ass. While the scene was well-played, the way Penelope was tied up made me think of one of those armless, legless torsos in a circus sideshow. Since her legs aren't where they're supposed to be, and her arms are hidden behind her, it sort of looked like he was raping a woman with no arms and legs! I know it's a strange criticism, and others might not have that same reaction, but I couldn't help but think about it.

Barker's next scene with Penelope has her tied to a chair with electrical cord, wrists behind her, with ankles corded to the legs of the chair. After again ballgagging her, her treats her to clothespins on her big tits, then removes the pins and gives her a harsh whipping session, as Penelope, tied immobile, can only sit and endure it. Things get even better as he removes her gag and gives her a new one, taping the end of the electical cord inside her mouth, and plugging the other end into the socket, shocking her so that her body writhes in uncontrollable spasm. Pace has long been one of Masters' most effective actresses, and as always, her work being tortured is quite convincing.

Barker's final torture with Penelope is an ingenious little setpiece, as she is tied, very nicely, atop a small stepladder, with her arms outstretched above her, again ballgagged, and has a rope tied around her waist and up through her pussy. The end of the rope is attached to a a pulley on the ceiling, and on the other end is a 150-pound box of concrete. Barker pushes the box off the little crate where it's propped up, forcing all the weight onto Penelope's swollen pussy. He pulls on the rope, and rocks the suspended box back and forth, to force more pressure on her sore pussy. He goes off and leaves her alone, and she manages to escape, with the heavy box slamming down to the ground when she takes the rope out from between her crotch, a nice, effective touch.

The tape finishes out with Barker again attacking Gayle and "forcing" her to suck his prosthetic dick, finally squirting cum into her mouth (My, they're doing so much with prosthetics today!). After spending virtually the whole tape listening to Barker's sadistic story and enthusiastically masturbating throughout, Gayle doesn't exactly act like she's having something done to her against her will. Her dilemma was much more exciting in the first Guilty, where she was at least tied down to the table first. Here, she clearly gets what she wants, as does Barker.

Guilty 2: Totemic has many good things going for it. Masters, almost unrecogizable as Barker, is again an excellent character, quite effectively playing a killer with a sadistic streak. When he tells Gayle all about his exploits with his last victim, it is as exciting to listen to as it is to watch! As the unfortunate victim, Penelope Pace once again is very believable, and her work with Masters is what makes this tape work so well. Some of the bondage and torture scenes are unique, so it's good to see Masters stretching and trying new things. The big letdown was giving Lisa Kinkaid no bondage scenes, and making her this sex-crazed animal, so that when she finally "gets" it, it's almost consensual. Face it, forcing is much more stimulating!